Skip to content
October cohort closes September 18
ProgramsSyllabusInstructorsAlumniPartnersTuition
Back to issue desk

Teaching note / 6 min read

Critique that does not crush people

A practical note on making critique specific, rigorous, and humane enough that students bring better work the next week.

2026-04-09

Design critique notes arranged on a table

Note 1

Start with the decision the work is trying to support.

Atlas publishes teaching notes as practical decision aids. This section turns the issue into a usable checklist for learners, mentors, and hiring managers.

Note 2

Separate taste, usability, and product risk before giving feedback.

Atlas publishes teaching notes as practical decision aids. This section turns the issue into a usable checklist for learners, mentors, and hiring managers.

Note 3

End critique with a next action, not a mood.

Atlas publishes teaching notes as practical decision aids. This section turns the issue into a usable checklist for learners, mentors, and hiring managers.

Related issue desk

Keep reading inside the Atlas teaching archive.

Portfolio desk

How to write a case study after a real project

The case study is not a project recap. It is a decision trail: constraints, tradeoffs, proof, and what changed because of the work.